Mike Reiss | Football notes

Merger of field and screen

Patriots want scouts, coaches on same page

Email|Print|Single Page| Text size + By Mike Reiss
Globe Staff / March 23, 2008

When the Patriots shuffled their coaching staff last month, they made a not-often-seen change, with Nick Caserio moving from receivers coach to director of player personnel.

Generally, coaches coach and scouts scout. There is the downstairs (coaching offices) and the upstairs (front office).

In his new role, which is still evolving, the 32-year-old Caserio will work under vice president of player personnel Scott Pioli. He will oversee parts of both the pro personnel and college scouting departments, helping fill some of the void created when director of college scouting Thomas Dimitroff was hired as Atlanta Falcons general manager.

Caserio's shift in responsibilities highlights how the Patriots view the melding of coaching and scouting, especially at this time of year, with the draft fast approaching (April 26-27).

A good scout must think like a coach, and a good coach must also be able to wear a scouting hat at times. The thinking is that Caserio's experience in both areas will strengthen the team's overall operation, because the essence of scouting isn't just identifying talented players, it's knowing how they will fit into a team's system.

"That overall linkage between the personnel/scouting department and what goes on downstairs from a coaching perspective is critical," said Caserio, who enters his eighth season with the Patriots, having shifted liberally between the two areas.

"That's why when your people evaluate college players, they need to understand how you do things, understand your system, and determine how those players will project to something they've never done before. It's very system-specific, and each team has its own criteria."

Some Patriots-specific questions this year are: How would one-gap defensive tackles Glenn Dorsey (LSU) and Sedrick Ellis (USC) fare in a two-gap style? Could defensive ends like Vernon Gholston (Ohio State) and Derrick Harvey (Florida) play outside linebacker in a 3-4 alignment? After playing outside linebacker in a 4-3 alignment, is Keith Rivers (USC) suited to play inside in a 3-4? Of top cornerbacks Antoine Cason (Arizona), Brandon Flowers (Virginia Tech), Mike Jenkins (South Florida), Leodis McKelvin (Troy), Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie (Tennessee State), and Aqib Talib (Kansas), who plays best in zone coverage and is smart enough to adjust to a diverse Patriots defensive package?

Caserio feels that working closely with Randy Moss and Wes Welker last season, and being involved in regular coaching meetings, should aid him in the job.

"You know first-hand the demands placed on our players because essentially when you're coaching a position, you're going through a week with them, so you can see exactly where they need to be, and what they need to do both physically and mentally," he said.

"From my perspective, now as I'm evaluating college players, you're looking for those type of qualities, those type of traits, to see if they will translate over and be successful in our program. That is also important to relay that information to our scouts so collectively we have a good understanding of what we're looking for.

"I think that's one thing that Bill [Belichick] and Scott have done a phenomenal job through the years. Scott understands what Bill is looking for in terms of players and that's why we've been able to find players who can perform, some at a higher level than others, and come in here and be productive in their role."

A native of Westlake, Ohio, and a teammate of offensive coordinator Josh McDaniels at John Carroll University, Caserio joined the Patriots in 2001 as a personnel assistant. He spent the 2002 season as a coaching assistant, before serving as an area scout the following year. From 2004-06, he was the team's director of pro personnel, before spending last year as receivers coach.

In running his own crossing route back to the personnel side, Caserio has been in catch-up mode over the last month, trying to learn as much as possible about draft prospects. Considering that Pioli and the team's scouts have been tracking the prospects for more than a year, there is much work to be done on his end.

From an overall perspective, however, most of the Patriots' scouting has been completed for the draft. Now they will send scouts and coaches to college Pro Days, and hold some private workouts with prospects. The private workouts are just a small piece of the overall puzzle.

"What you're really trying to do is spend time with the player, away from any sort of distractions, and get to know them as much as possible - his personality, how he thinks, what are his interests, what is important to him, how smart is he mentally, how does he learn the game," Caserio said.

"It allows you to meet individually with the player and get that information first-hand, which is probably the most important thing taken from it.

"Really, what you are doing is gathering as much information possible on the player, pooling it together, and saying, 'If you take a snapshot of the player, here it is.' "

When Caserio takes a snapshot of this year's draft, he sees a deep group of corners and offensive tackles, while the safety class is a bit shallow. He added that there has been no extra urgency given that the Patriots own the seventh overall selection.

"Regardless of where you pick, the biggest thing is making sure you have the correct evaluation of the player and you understand exactly how that player will fit and what role he might play within your team," he said.

Can’t develop QBs in a snap

In his visit to Boston College last week, Chiefs coach Herm Edwards pointed out that NFL teams can do a better job developing quarterbacks, which is partly why he felt it was important to visit with Matt Ryan.

"You're always looking for quarterbacks, and in my opinion, in our league you have to draft and develop them," he said. "That's why you see older quarterbacks still having the ability to play, because the position is one where we've gotten away from developing the guy."

That lack of development has helped a few quarterbacks on the senior circuit land some impressive contracts this season.

In Washington, age seemed to work in Todd Collins's favor when the 36-year-old signed a three-year, $9 million deal. In St. Louis, 37-year-old Trent Green landed a three-year, $8.9 million contract to be a backup.

Elsewhere, the Packers must consider how to fill the No. 2 spot now that Aaron Rodgers steps in for the retired Brett Favre. General manager Ted Thompson has quickly discovered that the options aren't very appealing.

With more than 60 quarterbacks starting at least one game in 2007 - a whopping total - Edwards's point is well-taken. It is surprising that more clubs don't invest more to develop young quarterbacks, considering the importance of the position.


Cherilus picking up steam
A contingent from the Miami Dolphins is scheduled to work out Boston College quarterback Matt Ryan and offensive tackle Gosder Cherilus on campus tomorrow, according to Cherilus's agent, Greg Diulus. That should generate some buzz in Miami, as the Dolphins own the top overall pick. Yet while Ryan is garnering more attention, not to be overlooked is how Cherilus (6 feet 6 inches, 314 pounds) has built momentum this offseason, most recently running impressive 40 times of 5.00 and 5.06 at BC's Pro Day. A projected mid-to-late first-round pick, Cherilus had dinner with a five-member contingent from Carolina that night - a group that included Panthers general manager Marty Hurney and offensive coordinator Jeff Davidson - and he has visits scheduled with the Falcons, Giants, Steelers, and Lions. The Vikings also are attempting to schedule a visit, while the Bears and Jets were previously in to work him out.

Trying to talk his way out
Bengals officials insist they aren't going to budge, even as chatty receiver Chad Johnson continues to make noise by saying he wants to play elsewhere. Johnson most recently said he doesn't plan to show up for the Bengals' offseason program, which starts tomorrow. Besides Johnson's vital presence in the offense, the Bengals aren't willing to move him because of the economic considerations. After paying him approximately $16 million over the last two seasons, the Bengals would take an $8 million salary cap hit by trading Johnson before June 1. While the Bengals aren't always known for their business acumen, even they can figure this one out.

Bush is all-business
Saints running back Reggie Bush plans to take part in the team's offseason program after spending most of last offseason in Southern California. After a dynamic rookie season, Bush felt he slipped last season, partly because he missed the final four games with a knee injury. That led critics to wonder whether Bush can succeed in the NFL. The 23-year-old Bush said he's spent plenty of time reflecting and is recommitting himself this offseason. "I'm taking a whole different approach this year in just how I go about my business and my life," he said.

Running back wants to be a returner
Former BC running back William Green hopes his performance in front of scouts from 22 teams at BC's Pro Day last week put him back on the league's radar after missing the last two seasons. Green's agent, Neil Schwartz, said he spoke to each of the NFL's 32 teams, letting them know of Green's mind-set. "He understands no one is going to take an economic risk in him," Schwartz said. "He's just looking for an opportunity to further his career, and I think people that see him would agree he's in tremendous shape and ready to play football." Green didn't run a great 40-yard dash last week - he slipped at the start - but he looked chiseled and recommitted.

Town without pity
It was a disappointing turn of events for New Hampshire quarterback Ricky Santos. Although he had been invited to participate in BC's Pro Day, Santos was ultimately deemed ineligible because his hometown of Bellingham was not close enough to BC. Agent Brad Blank pleaded Santos's case to the NFL, to no avail. So instead of working out in front of 22 NFL teams at an indoor facility, Santos worked out the next day at UNH in rainy/snowy conditions, with only three teams represented (Eagles, Patriots, Steelers). "It would have been a real opportunity for him," said Blank. "We looked into it, and the league explained that Bellingham is not in a major metropolitan region, as explained by Rand McNally. It's a shame."

She wrote the book
Ten months after Patriots defensive end Marquise Hill accidentally drowned in his hometown of New Orleans, his mother, Sherry, has completed a book on his life, "From the Cradle to the Bowl: The Marquise Hill Story." Hill overcame considerable adversity before he helped LSU win a national championship in 2003 and earned a Super Bowl ring with the Patriots in 2005. Sherry Hill is seeking a publisher for her book.

Extra points
By acquiring cornerback DeAngelo Hall and signing him to a reported seven-year, $70 million contract last week, the Raiders put an exclamation point on their shopping spree. Among Hall, defensive lineman Tommy Kelly, safety Gibril Wilson, and receiver Javon Walker, the team has written contracts totaling $214.5 million, with about $75 million in bonuses and guarantees . . . Browns outside linebacker Willie McGinest had his base salary reduced from $1.9 million to $900,000 for 2008 . . . Over the last few weeks, NFL Films eliminated 21 jobs, the Broncos handed out pink slips to eight employees, and the Sports Business Journal reported that the NFL is $9 billion in debt. Think there are a few things to talk about at next week's owners meetings in Palm Beach? . . . The Patriots' offseason program begins tomorrow at Gillette Stadium.

Did you know?
On the Patriots' adjusted $121 million salary cap, they have approximately $9.2 million in dead money, from players no longer on the roster. Running back Corey Dillon ($3.8 million), outside linebacker Rosevelt Colvin ($1.8 million), and tight end Kyle Brady ($1 million) account for the abundance of dead money.

NFL calendar

March 30-April 3: Annual meeting, Palm Beach, Fla.

April 26-27: Draft, New York.

May 19-21: Spring meeting, Atlanta.

Aug. 3: Pro Football Hall of Fame Game, Canton, Ohio (Indianapolis vs. Washington).

Aug. 26: Roster cutdown to maximum of 75 players.

Aug. 30: Roster cutdown to maximum of 53 players.

Sept. 4-8: 2008 regular season starts.

Mike Reiss can be reached at; Bob Hohler of the Globe staff contributed to this report; material from personal interviews, wire services, other beat writers, and league and team sources was used.

more stories like this

  • Email
  • Email
  • Print
  • Print
  • Single page
  • Single page
  • Reprints
  • Reprints
  • Share
  • Share
  • Comment
  • Comment
  • Share on DiggShare on Digg
  • Tag with Save this article
  • powered by
Your Name Your e-mail address (for return address purposes) E-mail address of recipients (separate multiple addresses with commas) Name and both e-mail fields are required.
Message (optional)
Disclaimer: does not share this information or keep it permanently, as it is for the sole purpose of sending this one time e-mail.