Coco CrispOF, Oakland Athletics
In three years with the Red Sox, Crisp managed to both excel and disappoint, and was benched during the 2007 World Series in favor of youngster Jacoby Ellsbury. The Oakland A's signed Crisp in 2010 for one year for $5 million with a club option. After an injury plagued 2010, Crisp had a solid 2011 season. While sporting an epic hairdo (left) at times, he hit .264 with 8 homers and led the American League with 49 stolen bases. Crisp is off to a tough start in 2012, posting a .156 batting average through 96 at-bats.