Red Sox 6, Blue Jays 1

Clay pigeons

Buchholz has Blue Jays eating out of his hand, outduels Halladay for win

Casey Kotchman broke his bat on this second-inning pitch from Roy Halladay, but he reached on a squibber to third and scored the second run of the inning. Casey Kotchman broke his bat on this second-inning pitch from Roy Halladay, but he reached on a squibber to third and scored the second run of the inning. (Mike Cassese/Reuters)
By Amalie Benjamin
Globe Staff / August 20, 2009

E-mail this article

Invalid email address
Invalid email address

Sending your article

Your article has been sent.

  • Email|
  • Print|
  • Reprints|
  • |
Text size +

TORONTO - Up until Tuesday night, when he caught a glimpse of Ricky Romero’s name as that evening’s Toronto starter, Clay Buchholz thought he had avoided his recent fate. He thought he would be pitching in this series against Romero, a pitcher having a good year, but certainly not having a year the caliber of Roy Halladay’s.

But Buchholz, fortunately or unfortunately, was wrong.

“I was like, well, that only leaves one guy for me to go up against and - lo and behold - it was Mr. Halladay,’’ Buchholz said. “It’s always fun going up against the other team’s best pitcher. If you want to succeed in this game for a long time, you’ve got to succeed against the guys that are the best in the game, and he’s definitely in that category.’’

Buchholz, though, could have been excused for an exasperated sigh or two. Another ace? But Buchholz never complained, not after he allowed just two runs in six innings to the Yankees and suffered a loss, not after he allowed just two runs in seven innings to the Tigers and suffered a loss. Not after facing CC Sabathia and Justin Verlander in his last two starts.

Not even after he drew Halladay last night. And any thoughts of self-pity were surely gone after his outing. Buchholz both outlasted and outpitched the Blue Jays’ Cy Young contender, resulting in a 6-1 Red Sox win at Rogers Centre.

“I felt really good the last three times out,’’ Buchholz said. “Went up against, even tonight, went up against a guy that’s in the running for Cy Young candidate. It’s hard to go out there and expect a lot of run support, so you want to keep the runs to a minimum.

“It’s been a whole lot better for me this year being back up as far as getting outs in key situations and making some good pitches and minimizing damage.’’

That left the Sox with the potential for a rare road sweep with Jon Lester on the mound against Brett Cecil tonight. Plus, paired with a Rangers loss to the Twins last night, the win put the Sox ahead by a game in the wild-card standings - and continued with the education of a young pitcher who seems to be getting the hang of the major leagues.

“He didn’t let the game get going too quick,’’ manager Terry Francona said. “Threw a couple fastballs in, used his pitches. Again, we knew going into this game that we were going to have to play a good game, and we did. And he did a very good job.’’

Using his changeup as his out pitch, as he has most of this season, Buchholz survived two innings in which he allowed three base runners. In the fourth, he had runners on first and second with one out and one run in (on Vernon Wells’s single to right). But Buchholz struck out Randy Ruiz swinging, and got Edwin Encarnacion to ground to second to end the inning.

He got out of it again in the sixth, after allowing three singles to load the bases with two outs before retiring Encarnacion again, this time Encarnacion slamming his bat down on the turf in frustration. The third baseman flied out to center field, ending the inning and finishing off the last real chance the Blue Jays had against any Sox pitcher.

Of that second Encarnacion at-bat, Buchholz said, he “was in hitter’s count [2-and-0], and I didn’t want to go 3-and-0 on him. Threw a fastball that was probably a hittable pitch, and it’s still a hard thing to do to hit a round ball with a round bat.

“Great hitter, hit 20-something home runs last year, definitely has the ability to make that game them up by one or tie ballgame. It’s just a matter of going out there and trusting your stuff sometimes.’’

“We’ve seen in the past where those innings have gotten away,’’ Francona said. “Like an infield hit with two outs that gets the bases loaded, then if he makes a mistake and somebody hit a grand slam - he gathered himself and made a pitch. That’s great to see. I didn’t think he had his sharpest breaking ball tonight, but he threw some real good changeups. Thought he got around a couple changeups. He did a good job. He really competed.’’

Coupled with his teammates’ ability to score five runs off Halladay, it resulted in a win. The authors of those runs have become predictable over the past week. Both David Ortiz and Jason Bay have turned hot, and both homered last night. Ortiz started the scoring with a homer to lead off the second inning, then the Sox got another run on a single up the middle by Alex Gonzalez that followed a Casey Kotchman single and stolen base.

Another run came in the fourth, on an RBI triple by Jacoby Ellsbury. Then Bay found his power stroke, blasting a Halladay pitch to the right of the foul pole in left field for a two-run homer. Two outs later, after five innings, Halladay was done, out in less than six innings for the first time in 42 straight non-injury starts. It was, in fact, only the third time this season that Halladay hadn’t reached the seventh inning - and the other two involved an injury and his first start after the injury.

“Usually he’s pounding the zone and he was a little more erratic with his command,’’ Bay said. “That’s why he’s been so successful against us, he goes right at you and he gets those strikes. For whatever reason, he wasn’t as crisp tonight.’’

Red Sox player search

Find the latest stats and news on:
V-Mart | Youk | Tim Wakefield |

Red Sox Twitter

    Waiting for

Tweets from the Nation

Check out what everyone on Twitter is saying about the Red Sox.   (Note: Content is unmoderated and may contain expletives)

Red Sox audio and video

Sox-related multimedia from around the web.