In Bethlehem, hopes overcome fears

Crowds return despite tensions in the region

Email|Print| Text size + By Dalia Nammari
Associated Press / December 25, 2007

BETHLEHEM, West Bank - Encouraged by renewed peace talks between Israel and the Palestinians, Christian pilgrims from around the world converged on Jesus' traditional birthplace yesterday and this morning to celebrate Christmas - a palpable contrast to the sparse crowds of recent years.

The diverse mix of people included festive American tourists, clergymen in brown flowing robes, and Palestinian scouts wearing kilts and playing bagpipes.

"I'm Catholic. I always wanted to see the beginning of Christianity, the whole history. It's something you grow up with," said Kristin Obeck, a 37-year-old schoolteacher from Richmond, Va.

The festive atmosphere, however, could not mask lingering tensions in the region. A heavy police deployment, the presence of Israel's massive separation barrier, and unease among Bethlehem's shrinking Christian population served as reminders of the tensions.

In his Christmas homily during midnight Mass, Latin Patriarch Michel Sabbah delivered a politically charged appeal for peace and love in the Holy Land - and independence for the Palestinian people.

"This land of God cannot be for some a land of life and for others a land of death, exclusion, occupation, or political imprisonment," said Sabbah, the first Palestinian to hold the position of top Roman Catholic official in the Holy Land.

In his homily, Sabbah criticized religious extremists and lamented the dwindling number of Christians. "To all of you Christians in this land, you who are tempted to emigrate, you who are the object of everyone's preoccupation, I say to you what Jesus told us: 'Do not be afraid,' " he said.

In the years after the 1993 Oslo peace accord, Bethlehem attracted tens of thousands of tourists for Christmas. But the number plummeted after the second Palestinian uprising in 2000.

Tourism has begun to recover as fighting has slowed. This year, it got a boost from the renewal of peace talks last month at a summit in Annapolis, Md.

While many celebrants appeared to be curious teenagers and other local residents, Israeli tourism officials said they expected 20,000 visitors to cross from Jerusalem into neighboring Bethlehem. They said that was an increase of about 50 percent over last year, though well below the peak years.

Tourism workers handed out sweets and flowers to pilgrims, and smiling Israeli soldiers posed for pictures with travelers.

Bethlehem's governor, Saleh Tamari, said all of the town's 5,000 hotel rooms were booked.

"If you can't be with family, it's good to be here where it all went down," said 23-year-old David Collen of Hickman, Neb., who is studying the Middle East at Tel Aviv University in Israel.

Tiago Martins, 28, from Curitiba, Brazil, said the new peace talks had prompted him to visit Bethlehem for the first time.

"The idea that it's a Christian city makes me more calm, and I think going to the West Bank is more comfortable since Annapolis," Martins said.

Priests and monks, tourists, Palestinian families, and police mingled in Manger Square outside the Church of the Nativity, the site where tradition holds Christ was born.

Vendors hawked beads, inflatable Santas, roasted peanuts, cotton candy, steamed corn, and Turkish coffee while residents watched the festivities from balconies and rooftops.

A four-story cypress tree, strung with lights and red and gold ornaments and topped with a yellow star, towered outside the church.

After nightfall, the square was lit in a sea of red and yellow lights and Christmas stars.

"This year is much better than the last seven years for tourism," said shopkeeper Jacques Aman, whose wooden handicrafts shop offered crosses, rosaries, and nativity scenes. "The atmosphere is better in general. There is relative calm, from the security standpoint."

Throughout the evening, choirs and orchestras performed hymns and Christmas carols in a multitude of languages.

Speaking to reporters as he came out of prayers at a Bethlehem mosque, Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas expressed hope that the renewed peace talks will bring about a Palestinian state in the coming year.

"We hope that this year will be the year of independence for the Palestinian people. God willing, this will be the year of security and stability and economic prosperity for the Palestinians," he said.

Sabbah began Christmas celebrations with his annual procession from Jerusalem to Bethlehem. He could only enter Bethlehem after passing through a massive steel gate in Israel's separation barrier - a stretch of concrete slabs built to keep suicide bombers from reaching Israel. Mounted police officers escorted Sabbah, in his flowing magenta robe, to the gate, and border police clanged it shut behind him.

The barrier was just one of the reminders of the area's lingering troubles. Hundreds of police were deployed in Manger Square and on neighboring rooftops, and before celebrants started flowing in, bomb squads walked through the streets sweeping cars and buildings for explosives.

Years of violence with Israel, infighting among rival Palestinian factions, and economic hardship caused by the barrier have contributed to the departure of Christians from Bethlehem. Officials say from 35 percent to 50 percent of the town's 40,000 people are Christian, compared with 90 percent in the 1950s.

"There is nothing for young people here," said Johnny Giacaman, a Bethlehem native who now lives in the United Arab Emirates but returned this year to visit his family. "Christians are leaving in high numbers. . . . If this continues, in five to 10 years the Church of the Nativity will be a museum."

more stories like this

  • Email
  • Email
  • Print
  • Print
  • Single page
  • Single page
  • Reprints
  • Reprints
  • Share
  • Share
  • Comment
  • Comment
  • Share on DiggShare on Digg
  • Tag with Save this article
  • powered by
Your Name Your e-mail address (for return address purposes) E-mail address of recipients (separate multiple addresses with commas) Name and both e-mail fields are required.
Message (optional)
Disclaimer: does not share this information or keep it permanently, as it is for the sole purpose of sending this one time e-mail.