your connection to The Boston Globe

Poll: Big gap in Western, Muslim views

But attitudes not uniform among countries surveyed

Muslims demonstrated in London recently against police tactics in antiterror raids and called for an apology. Two men were arrested in the raid then released without charges.
Muslims demonstrated in London recently against police tactics in antiterror raids and called for an apology. Two men were arrested in the raid then released without charges. (Getty Images)

WASHINGTON -- A ``deep attitudinal divide" exists between Western and Muslim publics, with Muslims in the Middle East, Asia, and Africa more critical of Westerners than vice versa, but attitudes are not monolithic and a ``middle ground" is particularly apparent among European Muslims, according to a survey released today.

Muslims and non-Muslims interviewed in 13 countries converge on few issues, but they agree that relations between Muslims and Westerners are bad, according to the survey by the Pew Research Center, a nonpartisan and nonprofit organization.

``The most salient findings include the extent to which Muslims have an aggrieved view of the West, and Westerners are skeptical and wary of Muslim values," said Andrew Kohut, the center's president.

People polled in six predominantly Muslim countries -- Turkey, Egypt, Jordan, Indonesia, Pakistan, and Nigeria -- blame Westerners for the strain in ties and mostly see Americans and Europeans as selfish, arrogant, immoral, and greedy, with opinions of the West and its people worsening over the past year, the survey suggested. In turn, majorities among the non-Muslims polled in most Western countries see Muslims as fanatical and lacking in tolerance.

But the non-Muslim Westerners interviewed were more divided in their attitudes toward Muslims than vice versa, poll results indicate. About 60 percent of the non-Muslims questioned in France, Britain, and Russia, as well as more than half of the Americans interviewed, maintain favorable opinions of Muslims overall. On the other hand, 36 percent of the non-Muslims surveyed in Germany and 29 percent in Spain view Muslims favorably.

About 27 percent of Pakistanis and 16 percent of Turks see Christians favorably; about 6 percent and 15 percent, respectively, have favorable views of Jews, according to the poll.

The survey was conducted as part of the Pew Center's Global Attitudes Project from March 31 to May 14. More than 14,000 people in 13 countries were interviewed by phone or in person. The study had a margin of error of 2 percent and 6 percent, depending on the country.

Overall, Kohut said, Westerners are less optimistic than Muslims in Europe or Muslim-majority countries about the viability of democracy in Muslim-majority countries and think more Muslims support suicide bombings and other violence against civilians than is the case.

For the second year running, the survey suggests there is increasing opposition among Muslim populations to violence targeting civilians in the name of Islam. Some 71 percent of polled Muslim Indonesians said such violence is never justified, compared with 66 percent last year; in Pakistan, the figure was 69 percent, up from 46 percent. Jordan has seen the steepest rise in the proportion of people opposed to extremist violence, up from 11 percent last year to 46 percent. Osama bin Laden's standing also continued to decline since polling last year, most significantly in Jordan, followed by Pakistan.

But ``a sizeable number of adherents," particularly among sampled Nigerian Muslims, still believe that violence against civilians is justifiable in defense of Islam, the survey indicated.

The poll attributes the trend against violence to Muslim countries' experiences with terrorism, including a triple suicide bombing in Amman, Jordan, in November that killed 60 people.

Moreover, with the exception of Turkey (at 39 percent), more than half of the Westerners and Muslims interviewed expressed concern over the global rise of Islamic extremism.

There is, however, no obvious correlation between diminishing support for terrorism and more positive perceptions of the West. Muslims in 4 out of 5 Muslim majority countries said Westerners are not ``respectful of women." Muslims also blame Western policies for their countries' lack of economic prosperity.

Publics in Western countries blame Muslim countries for what they perceive to be government corruption, lack of education, and Islamic fundamentalism.

But ``nothing highlights the divide between Muslims and the West more clearly," the survey suggested, than clashing views over the controversy about cartoons depicting the prophet Mohammed. First published in September in a Danish newspaper , they provoked riots and protests throughout the Muslim world.

Depending on the country, more than half to two-thirds of the Westerners surveyed blame the controversy on Muslim intolerance, while more than two-thirds of the Muslims questioned blame Western disrespect.

Moreover, solid majorities of Muslims living in Muslim countries and in Britain said they did not believe that Arabs carried out the attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, on the United States.

``It's one of the finds that makes you realize that deep emotional feelings get in the way of facts," Kohut said.

Muslims in Spain, Germany, and France, which was the scene of riots in predominantly North African and Muslim suburbs last fall, are more inclined than Muslims elsewhere, including Britain, to view non-Muslim Westerners as tolerant, generous, and respectful of women, the survey indicated.

Today (free)
Yesterday (free)
Past 30 days
Last 12 months
 Advanced search / Historic Archives