Back home

SectionsTodaySponsored by:
Top story

Judge's finding
Finding of Fact in the case:
-Coverage index
-HTML, 400K
-PDF file, 420K Line

-Reader thoughts about a Microsoft breakup Line

-Antritrust law Line

Past Cases
-Standard Oil
-American Tobacco Line



Key Players
-Bill Gates
-Other figures

Web sites
-Justice Dept.
-IBM Line

Microsoft latest in long US antitrust history

By Reuters, 11/04/99

IBM | ATT | StandardOil | ALCOA | AmericanTobacco

WASHINGTON - The U.S. antitrust action against Microsoft Corp. has been compared with the biggest battles in history between government trustbusters and some of the giants of American commerce.

Here is a list of some of the major cases since the Sherman Antitrust Act of 1890 came into force.

International Business Machines Corp.: Lasted from 1969 to 1982 and is the case most often cited when comparing with Microsoft. The largest legal case of any kind ever filed, according to University of Baltimore law professor Robert Lande.

The Justice Department charged that the company bundled hardware and software together, announced production schedules on "phantom machines" to delay possible customers from signing up with competitors, and gave special allowances to universities and other educational institutions. IBM had a market share of 65 percent, less than the government now says Microsoft has in key software.

The case was dismissed in 1982 after a delay that commentators said had made it a "relic." Nonetheless, IBM made an agreement with European governments that helped open up the computer market.

AT&T Corp.: Lasted from 1974 to 1982, when AT&T agreed to a consent decree with the government leading to the 1984 break-up of the company. The government said AT&T had monopolized the market for local and long-distance telephone service, along with equipment.

Standard Oil: The United States Supreme Court ruled for the government in 1911, ending a long antitrust case and opening the way for the break-up of John D. Rockefeller's Standard Oil. The resulting companies actually increased the value of the stock, making Rockefeller even richer than he had been.

Aluminum Co. of America: A 1945 case that the government fought through the World War II to end Alcoa's aluminum monopoly. In the end, the government sold aluminum war production plants to Reynolds Aluminum and Kaiser Aluminum, creating a competitive market.

American Tobacco: In 1946, the Supreme Court upheld the conviction of major tobacco companies for a conspiracy to monopolize and exclude competitors. Among other practices, the companies purchased tobacco they did not need to keep it out of the hands of smaller competitors.


Advertise on

Use to do business with the Boston Globe:
advertise, subscribe, contact the news room, and more.

Click here for assistance.
Please read our user agreement and user information privacy policy.

© Copyright 2000 Boston Globe Electronic Publishing, Inc.