Imperiled whales to get federal aid
Speed limits sought for ships along Atlantic
WASHINGTON - The government yesterday recommended a speed limit for commercial ships along the Atlantic coast, where collisions with the endangered right whale threaten its existence.
About 300 to 400 of the whales are left in the wild, and they migrate annually between their southeastern Atlantic breeding grounds to feeding areas off the Massachusetts coast, intersecting busy shipping lanes.
The head of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration said the new limit, the first to be instituted on the East Coast for a marine creature, was needed to assure its survival. The rule would set a speed limit of 11.5 miles per hour (10 knots) within 23 miles (20 nautical miles) of major mid-Atlantic ports and throughout the whale's breeding and feeding areas. The new regulation would cover ships 65 feet or longer and expire in five years if not renewed. Boats from federal agencies would be exempt.
"The bottom line is that this critically endangered species needs our help," said retired Navy Vice Admiral Conrad C. Lautenbacher, the agency's administrator.
But the latest version of the so-called ship strike regulation differs from a draft released more than a year ago that was delayed in part because of objections from Vice President Dick Cheney's office and White House economists over the accuracy of the science linking ship speed to whale deaths.
The ocean agency's "decision on these measures is based on the best data and scientific understanding available," White House environmental adviser James L. Connaughton said yesterday.
The option selected yesterday and released with an 850-page analysis of its environmental and economic impacts is narrower than the 34-mile-wide coastal speed zone first proposed for the mid-Atlantic coast by marine scientists in June 2006. Last year, in response to questions from the White House, agency specialists said moving the speed-limit zone closer to shore in that region would be less protective of right whales.
Yesterday, agency officials said the reduced area still covered 83 percent of all right whale sightings. Environmentalists said the changes were the latest to come from an administration that has consistently bucked scientific research.
"What we have seen over and over again where economics and partisanship and political interests bump up against the science, science loses," said Francesca Grifo, director of the Union of Concerned Scientist's Scientific Integrity Project.
The analysis published said the lower speed limit could cost ferry operators $8.6 million in lost revenues annually, and even have an effect on the whale watching industry, which is expected to lose $1.3 million under the proposed regulation. The economic impact would take more of a toll on high-speed vessels, which travel at 28 to 45 miles per hour, versus ships and boats traveling at the normal 14 to 18 miles per hour.
A spokesman for the World Shipping Council, a trade association for the shipping industry, said yesterday he saw no scientific or statistical support for a 11.5 miles-per-hour speed limit around mid-Atlantic ports. The association has argued that this area, stretching from New York to Savannah, Ga., is "where the science is the weakest and the economic impact is the greatest."
North Atlantic right whales have been protected by endangered species laws since 1970, yet despite warning systems around heavily traveled ports, aerial surveys to map whales in shipping lanes, and improvements in fishing gear, their population has yet to recover.
From 1970 to 1997, researchers documented 41 right whale deaths, 29 of which were caused by ship strikes or entanglement in fishing gear. From 1997 to 2001, about one to two right whales have died from ship strikes annually, federal officials said.
The speed limit would be the first to be set on the East Coast to protect a species. The National Park Service has a 15-miles-per-hour speed limit in place off Glacier
Environmentalists also criticized the delay, saying that since the rule was first proposed in June 2006 two right whales have died because of ship collisions.