your connection to The Boston Globe

House votes to approve president's warrantless wiretap bill

WASHINGTON -- The House approved a bill yesterday that would grant legal status to President Bush's warrantless wiretapping program with new restrictions. Republicans called it a test before the election of whether Democrats want to fight or coddle terrorists.

``You can't say that you're serious about taking on the terrorists if you stand up here every day and vote `no'," majority leader John Boehner of Ohio said before the bill passed 232-191.

``To always have reasons why you just can't vote `yes,' I think speaks volumes when it comes to which party is better able and more willing to take on the terrorists and defeat them," Boehner said.

Democrats shot back that the war on terrorism shouldn't be fought at the expense of civil and human rights. The bill approved by the House, they argued, gives the president too much power and leaves the law vulnerable to being overturned by a court.

``It is ceding the president's argument that Congress doesn't matter in this area," said Representative Chris Van Hollen, a Maryland Democrat.

The bill, sponsored by Representative Heather Wilson, a New Mexico Republican, give s legal status under certain conditions to Bush's warrantless wiretapping of calls and e-mails between people on US soil making calls or sending e-mails and those in other countries.

Under the measure, the president would be authorized to conduct such wiretaps if he:

  • Notifies the House and Senate intelligence committees and congressional leaders.

  • Believes an attack is imminent and later explains the reason and names the individuals and groups involved.

  • Renews his certification every 90 days.

    The Senate also could vote on a similar bill before Congress recesses at the end of the week. Leaders concede that differences between the versions are so significant they cannot reconcile them before the Nov. 7 congressional elections.

    For its part, the White House announced it strongly supported passage of the House version but wasn't satisfied with it, adding that the administration ``looks forward to working with Congress to strengthen the bill as it moves through the legislative process."

    But with Congress giving Bush the other half of his September antiterrorism agenda -- a bill setting conditions on how terrorism suspects are to be detained, interrogated, and tried -- Republicans shifted from lawmaking to campaign mode.

    After the House voted 253-168 to set rules on interrogations and military tribunal proceedings, Speaker Dennis Hastert was even more critical than Boehner.

    ``Democrat minority leader Nancy Pelosi and 159 of her Democrat colleagues voted today in favor of more rights for terrorists," Hastert said . ``So the same terrorists who plan to harm innocent Americans and their freedom worldwide would be coddled, if we followed the Democrat plan."

    Retorted Pelosi: ``I think the speaker is a desperate man for him to say that. Would you think that anyone in our country wants to coddle terrorists?"

    Today (free)
    Yesterday (free)
    Past 30 days
    Last 12 months
     Advanced search / Historic Archives