News your connection to The Boston Globe
Today's Globe  |   Latest News:   Local   Nation   World   |  NECN   Education   Obituaries   Special sections  

US report to be inconclusive on search for Iraqi weapons

WASHINGTON -- A much-anticipated interim report by the Bush administration's chief weapons hunter in Iraq will offer no firm conclusions about the former Iraqi government's chemical, biological, and nuclear weapons programs, senior officials said yesterday.

The weapons inspector, David Kay, is expected to present his report to Congress late next week -- an event that senior US officials had just weeks ago pointed to as providing a possible vindication for the administration's prewar claims that Iraq had stockpiles of chemical and biological weapons and had restarted its efforts to build a nuclear bomb.

But officials yesterday sought to play down expectations that Kay's report will contain any major revelations. Kay, who is in Washington this week finishing the document, is "still gathering information from the field," the CIA's chief spokesman, Bill Harolow, said yesterday. "Don't expect any firm conclusions. He will not rule in or rule out anything."

Criticism of the Bush administration's rationale for going to war, which was based largely on the threat posed by Iraq's weapons of mass destruction, has grown on Capitol Hill and overseas with the failure by US intelligence and military teams to discover any proscribed weapons in the five months since the government of president Saddam Hussein was toppled.

Just yesterday, Democrats seized on comments by Secretary of State Colin L. Powell -- still posted on the State Department's official website -- from Feb. 24, 2001, in which he told reporters during a trip to Egypt about the success of decade-old economic sanctions in containing Iraq. In his remarks, which were unearthed by an Australian journalist and broadcast on the BBC in Britain, Powell said Hussein "has not developed any significant capability with respect to weapons of mass destruction. He is unable to project conventional power against his neighbors."

Kay is CIA Director George Tenet's representative in Baghdad and directs the search for weapons of mass destruction being carried out by the 1,200-person Iraq Survey Group.

One senior intelligence official said recently that Kay's early analysis of Iraqi documents will prove that Saddam had the "intent" to resume chemical and biological weapons production once sanctions were lifted and United Nations inspectors were gone. "He also had scientists working in small groups on nonweapons work who could quickly be shifted over if weapons were needed," the senior official said.

Kay said last month he was initially focusing on Iraq's program to deceive UN inspectors and that his report would contain illustrations of how large that effort was, using it to indicate there were weapons to be hidden. After testifying before the Senate Armed Services Committee, Kay told reporters that his team had "found some physical evidence." He added: "I think it's very likely that we will discover remarkable surprises in this enterprise."

More recently, however, other officials, some of whom have spent time in Iraq, said the survey team had not gathered any substantial information, in part because the military members of Kay's group were threatening and arresting some Iraqi scientists and technicians.

The expectations for Kay's interim report have changed significantly in the last few weeks. On Sept. 7, Powell told NBC's "Meet the Press" that the report would show people "that there was no question that such weapons exist, existed, and so did the programs to develop one."

A week later, Vice President Dick Cheney, also on "Meet the Press," said, "I think David Kay will find more evidence as he goes forward, interviews people, as we get to folks willing to come forward now as they become more and more convinced that it's safe to do so, that, in fact, he [Saddam] had a robust plan, had previously worked on it, and would work on it again."

Globe Archives Today (free)
Yesterday (free)
Past 30 days
Last 12 months