your connection to The Boston Globe

Pennsylvanians rage about lawmakers' secretive pay raises

Little recourse seen for voters

HARRISBURG, Pa. -- Editorial writers and columnists have called it a mugging of state taxpayers, the Great Harrisburg Caper of 2005, an act of legislative thievery. ''Greed gone wild," one angry voter wrote.

Public outrage over a hefty pay raise Pennsylvania lawmakers voted themselves in the dead of night a month ago has nagged them throughout their summer vacation and shows no signs of going away.

Not only did legislators increase their salaries 16 percent to 34 percent -- reaching at least $81,050, more than in any state except California -- but they also crafted the package in secret without debate or public scrutiny, then left town.

Even more galling to Pennsylvanians, lawmakers found a way around a constitutional provision barring them from collecting any salary increase during the term in which it is approved.

The pay raise bill, based on the authority of a court ruling nearly two decades old, lets lawmakers start collecting the raises 16 months early.

''I've never seen this kind of anger," said Senator Patricia Vance, a Republican who received critical e-mails even though she voted against the bill and declined to collect her raise. ''I've [been called] a lot of names."

Newspapers across Pennsylvania continue to publish angry editorials and letters from readers. A radio talk-show host is circulating a petition calling for the repeal of the raises, which also apply to judges and certain top executive-branch officials, and is organizing a protest for when lawmakers reconvene in late September.

Two websites have sprung up urging voters to overhaul the Legislature or toss out incumbents.

''Pennsylvania legislative leaders and every legislator who voted for a 16 percent pay raise should hang their heads in shame," William G. Williams wrote in a letter to The Patriot-News of Harrisburg. ''It was a scandalous example of greed gone wild."

The pressure is having some effect: As of Tuesday, nine lawmakers had declared changes of heart and said they would not accept the increase this term. But nearly 150 of the 252 sitting lawmakers are sticking to their decision to immediately take the raise of at least $950 a month.

Governor Ed Rendell, a Democrat who signed the bill into law, said he has received nearly 1,000 letters, e-mails, and phone calls criticizing the decision. After having previously said only that the special payments were legal, he said Tuesday that legislators who turned them down ''did the right thing."

Politically, the big question is: Will the whole thing have blown over by next year's general election?

''The hope is do it, get it done . . . have people forget about it," said Don Kettl, director of the Fels Institute of Government at the University of Pennsylvania.

Unlike 24 other states, Pennsylvania does not allow voters to try to override the Legislature by petitioning for a statewide ballot.

''It's a cabal over there," said Bob Durgin of WHP Radio in Harrisburg, who has gathered more than 12,000 petition signatures and is organizing a protest rally to greet lawmakers when they return from vacation. ''It's just a secret little society that does business behind closed doors."

House Speaker John Perzel, a Republican, defended the Legislature's handling of the raises and accused the news media of overplaying the story.

''It's been a slow news month," Perzel said.

He and other supporters of the law said legislators were underpaid and the raise merely brings their salaries in line with other top officials in the state.

The law links the present and future salaries of top officials in state government to similar posts in the federal government.

Legislators' $81,050 base salary is 50 percent of a congressman's salary. State Supreme Court justices get the same $171,800 as a US circuit judge.

Since the 2 a.m. vote July 7, voters have remained agitated. A lawsuit has been filed in state court challenging the legality of paying the raises early as unvouchered expenses, though no hearing date has been set. A ruling against the unvouchered expenses would nullify the entire law, including their raises.

In Massachusetts, a two-year, 4.1 percent pay raise that went into effect Jan. 1 lifted the base pay for lawmakers to about $55,500 a year.

Pop-up GLOBE GRAPHIC: In other states
Today (free)
Yesterday (free)
Past 30 days
Last 12 months
 Advanced search / Historic Archives