your connection to The Boston Globe

Ohio foes of gay bishop defy Episcopal Church

FAIRLAWN, Ohio -- Launching a new front in the Episcopal Church conflict over the appointment of an openly gay bishop, six defiant congregations joined yesterday in a confirmation service led by bishops acting without permission from the Diocese of Ohio.

Under Episcopal law and liturgy, confirmations are performed only by local bishops or visiting bishops approved by the head of the host diocese -- in this case Bishop J. Clark Grew II of Cleveland.

"This business against the diocesan bishop is simply defiant and that's why it's troubling," said Daniel England, a church spokesman. "It violates our constitution and canons."

The six congregations are part of a nationwide protest movement of conservative Episcopalians who oppose homosexual activity.

The issue exploded last year when the church's national convention approved the elevation of the denomination's first openly gay bishop, V. Gene Robinson of New Hampshire.

Grew joined a majority of Episcopal bishops in voting for Robinson, and yesterday service was a personal snub of his authority.

As the rift over gay clergy has deepened in the Episcopal Church, a key issue has been what to do about conservative parishes within dioceses whose bishops supported Robinson.

Conservatives are demanding substitute leadership from outside their dioceses, bypassing their regular resident bishops, and say bishops have rarely provided that for them.

The issue of oversight will top the agenda when the nation's Episcopal bishops meet behind closed doors at Navasota, Texas, starting Friday.

Yesterday's confirmations, performed in an Eastern Orthodox church 25 miles south of Cleveland, represented a warning that if the bishops don't give conservatives what they want, further protests and disruptions are inevitable.

The confirmations of about 110 people of varying ages were conducted by five retired Episcopal bishops and one bishop from the international diocese. About 800 people attended.

"This is an emergency measure we took responding to the controversial actions of last summer," said retired Texas Bishop the Rev. Maurice Benitez, referring to Robinson's appointment. "We came in and we confirmed about 100 people."

Joining Benitez were C. FitzSimmons Allison, retired bishop of South Carolina; William Cox, retired assistant bishop of Oklahoma; Alex Dickson, retired bishop of west Tennessee; William Wantland, retired bishop of Eau Claire, Wis.; and the Rev. Robinson Cavalcanti, bishop of northern Brazil.

The presence of Cavalcanti underscored that in the international Anglican Communion, in which the Episcopal Church is the US branch, most bishops strongly oppose gay activity.

Last October, an emergency meeting of heads of the Anglican Communion's 38 branches jointly stated that bishops must respect the autonomy of each other's dioceses.

But that meeting also called upon the Episcopal Church to "make adequate provision for Episcopal oversight of dissenting minorities." In response, the head of the Episcopal Church, Presiding Bishop Frank Griswold, and his advisers proposed what they called "supplemental episcopal pastoral care."

The American Anglican Council, a conservative group that played a role in organizing yesterday's confirmations, found that plan unacceptable because the local bishop would retain power to approve visiting bishops.

Today (free)
Yesterday (free)
Past 30 days
Last 12 months
 Advanced search / Historic Archives