Maine kills bill to ban bear traps

By Glenn Adams
Associated Press / May 3, 2011

E-mail this article

Invalid E-mail address
Invalid E-mail address

Sending your article

Your article has been sent.

Text size +

AUGUSTA, Maine — Maine lawmakers voted yesterday to continue allowing bear hunters in the state to use traps and dogs, maintaining the status of the law since voters made the same decision seven years ago.

While voting 11 to 0 to kill a bill that would have outlawed the use of traps and dogs, the Inland Fisheries and Wildlife Committee kept alive other bear hunting proposals for further consideration.

Two members were absent from yesterday’s vote.

Similar proposals have come up and been rejected since 2004, when Maine voters defeated a referendum proposal to outlaw bear trapping and hunting bear with bait or dogs. Supporters of the proposed ban had portrayed baiting, trapping, and use of dogs as unsportsmanlike and unnecessary.

No one spoke in favor of the latest bill yesterday before the committee rejected it. But other bear hunting bills are still pending in committee following hearings.

A bill seeking to establish a spring bear hunting season, from the third Monday in May to the fourth Saturday in June, drew mixed reactions.

Representative Dennis Keschl, Republican of Belgrade, said he was motivated to sponsor the bill by a constituent who said the spring hunt would help Maine sporting camps.

Keschl acknowledged divided views on the bill, including some who think it’s a bad idea and others who believe a strong bear population is related to the decrease of deer in some parts of Maine.

The state Inland Fisheries and Wildlife Department, which testified as neutral on the bill, said a spring hunt can be an appropriate bear management option that does not adversely affect the state’s bear population.

“Nevertheless, when discussing the merits of spring bear hunting, there is more to be considered than just biology,’’ said department biologist Sandy Ritchie.

A significant increase in the bear harvest and reduction in the bear population “may undermine the economic contribution that bears provide to the rural economy,’’ Ritchie said.

Ritchie also noted that the spring hunt has precedent and was conducted as late as 1981, when the state stopped it because the bear kill exceeded management objectives.

An opponent of the spring hunt bill, Katie Lisnik of the Humane Society of the United States, said spring bear hunting will “without a doubt, result in the orphaning and death of a number of bear cubs who are entirely dependent on their mothers for sustenance, care, and protection.’’

Lisnik called a spring hunt “reckless, inhumane, and unnecessary,’’ and said three-fourths of the states that allow bear hunting prohibit spring bear hunting.

A third bill would shift the open season for hunting bears with dogs back by one week. Doing so would reduce an overlap with the open season on bear without dogs, said Representative Stephen Wood, Republican of Sabattus.