For officialdom in Boston, the annual South Boston St. Patrick's Day parade --once a staple of political life -- has lost its shine. Today, the Globe reports that, since a deal between MassEquality and parade organizers seems unlikely, most of Boston's elected officials are planning to skip the event on Sunday. So are all 10 gubernatorial candidates. So is Mayor Marty Walsh.
In the past few weeks, as accusations have flown and compromises have failed, some have started to wonder whether this parade is worth the trouble anymore. Is the St. Patrick's Day parade a tradition worth fighting for? Should we start over with a new kind of Southie heritage celebration? Or should we scrap the whole thing and hang out in another neighborhood? Share your thoughts in the comments, or tweet them to @BostonComment.
Good riddance to bad rubbish
Itís time to get rid of the St. Patrickísí Day parade. This supposed celebration of Irish pride and culture has instead become a paean to bigotry. Itís an embarrassment to Boston. It should embarrass Irish-Americans. It surely embarrasses this one. Not a single politician should march. Nobody should, actually, save for maybe John ďWackoĒ Hurley and his pathetic band of Allied War Veterans, whose parade glorifies warfare at a time when veterans and most of America ó after 11 years of bloodshed ó want nothing more than peace.
Margery Eagan, @MargeryEagan
The Boston Herald
Mayor Walsh still looking for the show to go on
Status: Officially hypocritical
Guys, the Southie St. Patrick's Day Parade is now getting the meme treatment. pic.twitter.com/Zj04rhItaH— Garrett Quinn (@GarrettQuinn) March 4, 2014
Keep the tradition, change with the times
I donít think itís time to get rid of the parade altogether, but I think itís disgusting and pretty abhorrent that anyone should be discriminated against for any of their thoughts or feelings, and I donít think a group should not be allowed to walk simply because of their sexual orientation.
Irish heritage? Please.
It was only as I got older that I realized how much booze had become an integral, insidious part of the parade. People got loaded, threw up on their shoes, peed on sidewalks, punched the air and each other....Go to the paradeís official website, and the first thing you see is a link directing you to bars where you can celebrate your Irish heritage by having a few cold ones. I might be more inclined to accept the parade was all about honoring veterans if the website gave as much prominence to a link where people could donate their beer money to, say, the Wounded Warrior Project, Fisher House, or Home Base... Iíve seen intrinsically disordered acts of grave depravity on and off Broadway during and after some parades, and none of them involved homosexuals.
Kevin Cullen, @GlobeCullen
Boston Globe columnist
Go your own way
Should we also let the anti-Catholic Orange Order of Belfast march in protest of St. Patrick's Day right in the middle of Southie's parade? Preferably armed to the teeth? Obviously not. My point is that the theme of the St. Patrick's Day Parade is to celebrate St. Patrick's Day. It's not to bash people who like St. Patrick's Day. It's not to air the grievances of our beloved gay brethren (legitimate though they may be), nor to protest against nuclear power, capitalism, or the mistreatment of animals. People who want to parade about those things ought to march in their own parade, because bringing so many irrelevant side issues into it tramples on the rights of the parade organizers to express what they're trying to express. A parade that's about everything is effectively about nothing and therefore not worth having at all.
Over Wacko's dead body
Marty Walsh told me yesterday heís spent way too much time on this issue. But then, itís a lot like our relations with Cuba. Nothing is likely to change until the Castros depart. So it is with our St. Patrickís Day Parade. Not much is likely to change so long as John ďWackoĒ Hurley draws a breath.
Boston Herald columnist
The author is solely responsible for the content.
Boston.comment is an exchange for ideas about Boston and beyond, brought to you by the Boston Globe editorial page and edited by Globe columnist Joanna Weiss. We're the sponsor of Boston.com's #LabDebates and the creator of the Choose Your Own Adventure mayoral game.
A note on comments: Be honest, be open, be polite. And be warned: Personal attacks will be removed.