RadioBDC Logo
| Listen Live
< Back to front page Text size +

Instant scorecard: Who won the debate?

Posted by Joanna Weiss October 29, 2013 09:15 PM


Round three of Connolly v. Walsh is over. Twitter is on fire. The spin machines are cranking. So to sort through what we watched last night, we turned to some of our favorite pundits. Here are their takes on last night's winners and losers. Add yours to the comments, or tweet them @BostonComment. (And to see the candidates talking more casually, check out "My Dinner With Larry," our campaign mini-films.)

John Connolly won another debate - but not necessarily the election - on the same, old anti-union points. He lost leadership points when he ducked rather than say if he would vote yes or no on an Eastie casino.
Joan Vennochi, @Joan_Vennochi
Globe columnist

Debate was a draw. Connolly has been consistently good in these forums whereas Walsh has improved markedly. But neither candidate overwhelmed the other tonight. This final debate isn't likely to move the serially undecided voting bloc.
Peter Ubertaccio, @ProfessorU
Political science professor, Stonehill College

I think Walsh won for most-improved and Connolly won for most honest answer, saying he wouldn't want a casino next door to his house. And I think it's interesting that, in this race, you win voters over (or attempt to) by readily admitting how racist Boston is.
Hilary Sargent, @lilsarg and Chartgirl blog

Walsh needed to convince skeptical voters that he isn’t in the pocket of labor unions. He failed. Connolly needed to draw distinctions between himself and Walsh without coming across like a sourpuss. He succeeded, for the most part.
Lawrence Harmon, Globe Columnist
"John Connolly Makes a Better Case"

I gave it to Connolly. He was clearer, sharper, and more focused -- except on the East Boston casino vote, where he was, um, fuzzier, less sharp, and more evasive. Walsh is not a very good debater, truth be told. And his answer on the arbitration legislation makes little or no sense.
Scot Lehigh, @GlobeScotLehigh
Globe columnist

Walsh projected more confidence in this debate than he has in the previous two. But when faced with tough questions — such as whether he can stand up to unions — he just turned testy. That’s a side few of us have seen before. And one I suspect few want to see again.
Farah Stockman, @fstockman
Globe columnist, "Where Was Mr. Nice Guy?"

Memo to Marty Walsh: Don't ask your opponent in the closing moments of a widely televised debate to name three things he did to create jobs. John Connolly definitely had the better performance, but this debate surely won't settle the race.
Dante Ramos, @danteramos
Globe deputy editorial page editor

Replay: The At-Large #LabDebates

Posted by Alex Pearlman October 22, 2013 09:50 AM

Continuing our coverage of the city's drama-tinged 2013 election, we held two more Lab Debates. This time, we invited the eight at-large city council candidates to participate in two debates, split into two groups of four.

Watch the full debates here, and stay tuned for short clips, to be posted soon!

Monday, Oct. 21

Tuesday, Oct. 22

#LabDebates: The At-Large Edition

Posted by Alex Pearlman October 21, 2013 09:38 AM


Monday and Tuesday this week, the Boston.Comment team will host another round of Lab Debates, streamed live from the Globe Lab. This time, though, we're focusing on the at-large city council election, where eight candidates vie for four open seats.

You can stream the debates live here and on the homepage of at 1 p.m. Make sure to follow along on Twitter as well, and tweet your questions with the hashtag #LabDebates.


What's the best public art in Boston?

Posted by Joanna Weiss October 7, 2013 01:12 PM

ritchie mural 2.jpg
New in town

When it comes to public art, how does Boston rate? According to the Globe's Sebastian Smee, it's generally too bronze, too morbid, and too dull to be worthy of a first-date conversation. But within his broad critique of Boston's overcautious art, Sebastian also named some high points; Lilli Ann Killen Rosenberg’s “City Carpet/Hopscotch” mosaic on School Street; Michio Ihara’s “Wind Wind Wind" on State Street. Some might add "Play Me, I'm Yours," the temporary collection of 75 pianos placed around the city.

Last summer, we asked the mayoral candidates to name their favorite examples of Boston public art. We've reprinted Marty Walsh and John Connolly's picks below, and posed the same question to some artists around town. Now, we want to hear from you. Look over this Pinterest board of Boston public art -- or take a walk around your neighborhood -- then share your favorites in the comments, or tweet us @BostonComment.


The shutdown: A day in tweets

Posted by Joanna Weiss October 1, 2013 10:27 AM


Time will tell whether this government shutdown ends with a bang or a whimper. But so far, it has been heavy on the tweets. Government agencies took to Twitter to announce their shutdown plans. Federal beneficiaries described the effects of the impasse. The Voyager spacecraft declared, in a decidedly un-machine-like way, that it would stop tweeting until further notice. Some of these pronouncements could be cause for dismay. Others might not be great losses to the nation. What follows is the story of the shutdown, via Twitter. Add your reactions to the comments -- or tweet us @BostonComment, if you’re still in operation.


Don't go anywhere -- new passports won't be issued

A shutdown might be fleeting, but a pun will last a lifetime

Just hold it

Essential services are still in operation

...but transparency is not essential

Game off

All is not lost


Nice work, earthlings

About Boston.comment

weiss.jpegBoston.comment is an exchange for ideas about Boston and beyond, brought to you by the Boston Globe editorial page and edited by Globe columnist Joanna Weiss. We're the sponsor of's #LabDebates and the creator of the Choose Your Own Adventure mayoral game.

Our producer is Alex Pearlman, with contributions (and sea monsters) from Noah Guiney. To join the conversation, post a comment, tweet with our daily hashtag, or follow us on Twitter @BostonComment.

A note on comments: Be honest, be open, be polite. And be warned: Personal attacks will be removed.

Top comments


Browse this blog

by category