“How to Make It in America,” HBO’s new comedy, and “Entourage,” HBO’s much older comedy, are both about money. They’re also both about young men in the throes of the American Dream, which includes professional success and, oh yeah, sex.
But “How to Make It in America,” which premieres Sunday at 10, and “Entourage” are nonetheless extremely different shows. They’re a virtual study in opposites. “How to Make It in America” is set in the hip backwash of New York City, rather than the sleek mansions of LA. It’s as street-textured a show -- with shots of graffiti-strewn subway stations and tattooed skateboarders -- as “Entourage” is limousine-bound. And the two leads -- Bryan Greenberg’s Ben and Victor Rasuk’s Cam -- are constantly trying to scrape together a fraction of the money that the “Entourage” guys drop in one night at the clubs. They’re eating street dogs, not sushi.
Which is to say, “How to Make It in America” (watch it here) does not offer the same pornographic allure of “Entourage.” But it has other charms, as it draws viewers into a little slice of crowded Manhattan life. Ben and Cam are hoping to make it in the fashion world, but not in the “Ugly Betty” elite world of Vogue and Fashion Week. They want to create their own line of jeans, which takes them to the back-alleys and the docks to buy fabric and to the gruff manager of a clothing factory, who might help them put together a prototype. They’re good boys, but they’re walking close to the fringe.
By night, they’re the random guys hanging out at art openings and late parties; by morning, they’re hungover and still broke. As they try to piece together funding for their jeans project, they deal with Cam’s ex-convict cousin, Rene, an explosive guy who loans money to them with many strings attached. Rene, played by Luis Guzman with a hint of Joe Pesci from “Goodfellas” about him, is a comic figure, but menacing, too. Ben and Cam are clearly mixing with the wrong guy, despite the fact that he’s part of Cam’s family.
I was skeptical about seeing Greenberg -- from “October Road” -- playing a guy who might wear scruffy clothes and have a little B.O.; but he pulls it off nicely. He’s a dreamer always on the verge of giving up. He’s still in love with his ex-girlfriend, Rachel (Lake Bell), but she has clearly tired of his inveterate struggle to make it on his own, his way, and she has a new boyfriend. As his former Fashion Institute professor, played by Griffin Dunne, tells him, Ben is a talented guy who’s just not very good on the follow through. He desperately wants to reverse his luck, and he desperately wants to give up, too.
I think “How to Make It in America” has a lot going for it, if show creator Ian Edelman can keep from indulging in New York hipster clichés. The characters -- including Rachel’s self-conscious boss, beautifully played by Martha Plimpton -- have some depth, and the milieu has plenty of gritty urban poetry. It’s not as flashy as “Entourage,” which is appealing -- but which may ultimately have an impact on whether it will make it on HBO or not.
About Viewer Discretion
ContributorsKatie McLeod is Boston.com's features editor.
Rachel Raczka is a producer for Lifestyle and Arts & Entertainment at Boston.com.
Emily Wright is an Arts & Entertainment producer at Boston.com.
Sarah Rodman is a TV and music critic for the Boston Globe.
Meghan Colloton is a Things to Do and Arts & Entertainment producer at Boston.com.
Michael Brodeur is the assistant arts editor for the Boston Globe, covering pop music, TV, and nightlife.