Josh Grobans clean pop lacks wit and charm
By: Marc Hirsh | Globe Correspondent
October 29, 2013
Josh Groban is popularly viewed as an operatic (or quasi-operatic, anyway) singer, but that has little to do with his material; for the most part, that is typical coolness-be-damned adult contemporary pop, with a few romance-language numbers. And despite the too-prominent orchestra, it usually does not characterize his arrangements. It is Grobans vocal approach, which refuses to place beauty secondary to emotional truth like pop music and doesnt rely on expressing internal emotion like musical theater.
Instead, Groban delivers his melodies cleanly and unambiguously, albeit filtered through heavy vibrato and a slight nasality. Monday night at TD Garden, he did exactly that for nearly two hours, often proving himself less a singer than a vocalist in the process. Songs that cried out for earthiness, like the Latin-tinged Un Alma Más, were left wanting, and the immense charm and wit he showed when simply talking to the audience seemed to vanish once the music started.
Grobans duet with opening act Judith Hill on The Prayer laid that bare. Her first verse began the song with emotive pop vocals before he joined her with his warbly croon, and the contrast between the two styles revealed Grobans habit of running roughshod over the concept of interpretive singing. Whatever the symphonic Celtic folk of She Moved Through The Fair conveyed came from the words and the tune themselves. Groban let them do the work and stayed largely out of their way.
Sometimes it was enough. There was a genuine power in the way that the chorus of Alla Luce Del Sole, with its sweeping electric guitar and anthemic drum hits, galvanized the song, and Remember When It Rained similarly worked best when it succumbed to electric bombast on the coda. Near the end, with the accumulated weight of the concert behind it, Stevie Wonders I Believe (When I Fall in Love It Will Be Forever) was a fittingly overwhelming vow of romantic certainty. But Groban was not overwhelmed.
In fitting with her reality-show pedigree, The Voice contestant Hill opened with a solo-piano medley of staples Feeling Good, Ill Be There, and Youve Got A Friend before moving on to her own soulful material.
Marc Hirsh can be reached at firstname.lastname@example.org. Follow him on Twitter @spacecitymarc.
Thanks for your submission!
We'll approve and post your submission as fast as we can.
At his Oct. 28 show at TD Garden, Josh Groban delivered "melodies cleanly and unambiguously" for a nearly two-hour set featuring a duet with opening act and "The Voice" contestant Judith Hill.