Price: $2.99 per half gallon

The winner, for tasting just like milk should. A few found it thin, but others remarked on its creaminess and body: “Nice, full-rounded taste”; “smooth and creamy, best of the bunch.” “Taste really stood out,” said one taster, who picked it as his favorite. One true connoisseur found it a little watery, but he dubbed it the winner of another very important test: “This one would go best with cookies.”