On Science

All creatures, great and overrated

Email|Print|Single Page| Text size + By Anthony Doerr
March 16, 2008

Big Brain: The Origins and Future of Human Intelligence
By Gary Lynch and Richard Granger
Palgrave Macmillan, 259 pp., illustrated, $26.95

Your Inner Fish: A Journey Into the 3.5-Billion-Year History of the Human Body
By Neil Shubin
Pantheon, 229 pp., illustrated, $24

Twenty years ago my high school biology teacher drew a leafless tree of life on the blackboard. At the base of its trunk were single-celled protists, and as the tree extended upward, it forked into the plant and animal kingdoms. The limbs of each kingdom quickly subdivided into phyla: ferns and flatworms, conifers and echinoderms. Toward the top of the tree, a branch was labeled "chordates," and at the very top of that branch's mess of twigs, our teacher labeled the highest shoot "human beings."

This sort of diagram is called a phylogenetic tree and offers a succinct representation of the diversity of life. It beautifully illustrates the genetic connections between organisms as disparate as a cheetah and an eelworm. It says: We are all cousins. Darwin used the analogy in "The Origin of Species"; international biologists are currently assembling an amazing example at

What I've been realizing lately, though, is that by placing humans at the very top of the tree, my high school teacher may have done his students a mild disservice. The implication was that big-brained Homo sapiens, perched at the top of the topmost twig, formed the pinnacle of evolution. This is a fallacy. Evolution proceeds by blind chance, not by design. We are adapted creatures, but we are not optimized creatures. As counterintuitive as it might seem, it's inaccurate to suggest that humans are more evolved than, say, horseshoe crabs, which have been living and dying for 400 million years.

Two esteemed brain scientists, Gary Lynch and Richard Granger, in their new book, "Big Brain," call the top-of-the-tree paradigm "species chauvinism." "We often," they write, "fall into a fallacy of thinking - an almost irresistible fallacy - imagining that a feature or characteristic that we possess must have been carefully built that way, just for us."

In "Big Brain," the authors reintroduce the Boskops: an extinct, controversial, 10,000-year-old African hominid that possessed a brain about 30 percent larger than ours is now. The Boskops had little frames and massive heads, and their mere presence in the fossil record throws the idea of unidirectional evolutionary progress into question.

Were the Boskops more intelligent than we are now? More capable? If they were, why did they die out? Lynch and Granger offer up several theories. Ultimately they conclude that the Boksops "would far exceed contemporary people in at least some mental capacities."

"Big Brain" is about more than the fossil remains of a few large-headed ancestral relatives. Sometimes dry, sometimes riveting, the book tracks the evolutionary development of the human brain and ultimately argues that pure chance, in concert with natural selection, has given us our currently unmatched cognitive powers. Along the way, the authors are exceedingly careful to point out that evolution never proceeds in a straight line but rather takes a path "of apparently aimless wandering interrupted by surprising leaps."

Neil Shubin, in his wonderful first book, "Your Inner Fish," looks at the same issue from a slightly different vantage point. Why, he wonders, do we hiccup? Why do we get hernias, and hemorrhoids, and why do we tear up our knees? Why do the cranial nerves in our skull meander and twist through nightmarish roller-coaster turns before plugging into their various destinations?

The answers, says Shubin, lie in the 3-plus-billion-year history of life itself. "Like a cake recipe passed down from generation to generation," he writes, "the recipe that builds our bodies has been passed down, and modified, for eons." Like Lynch and Granger, Shubin uses recent genetic discoveries to show how this human-building "recipe" we pass on to our kids isn't always streamlined, straightforward, or even rational. Each of us possesses, for example, a huge family of genes dedicated to the sense of smell, but only a tiny percentage of them actually work. Why would we possess genetic sequences we no longer use? Shubin puts it this way: We were once fish. And we were once amphibians. And reptiles. And pond scum.

Shubin is a professor of comparative anatomy, so he spends lots of time thinking about bodies: how they're put together, why we have them. He's also a career paleontologist who made world headlines a few years ago for discovering a transitional species called Tiktaalik, a 375-million-year-old fossil fish that possessed a shoulder, elbow, and proto-wrist. And, perhaps surprisingly, he spends lots of time in his lab messing around with embryos. In "Your Inner Fish," he fuses all three of these worlds - paleontology, anatomy, and genetics - into a remarkably readable trip through the deep history of our own bodies.

There is, Shubin demonstrates, a whole tree of life inside each of us. "If you know how to look," he writes, "our body becomes a time capsule that, when opened, tells of critical moments in the history of our planet and of a distant past in ancient oceans, streams, and forests." What I loved about "Your Inner Fish" was the way it made me feel part of a vast continuum of time and species. We are not at all separate from the rest of the living world; there is no "animal kingdom," with its suggestion of a king enthroned atop a hierarchy. We are only one twig among a near-infinity of twigs.

Anthony Doerr is the author of ‘‘The Shell Collector,’’ ‘‘About Grace,’’ and ‘‘Four Seasons in Rome.’’

more stories like this

  • Email
  • Email
  • Print
  • Print
  • Single page
  • Single page
  • Reprints
  • Reprints
  • Share
  • Share
  • Comment
  • Comment
  • Share on DiggShare on Digg
  • Tag with Save this article
  • powered by
Your Name Your e-mail address (for return address purposes) E-mail address of recipients (separate multiple addresses with commas) Name and both e-mail fields are required.
Message (optional)
Disclaimer: does not share this information or keep it permanently, as it is for the sole purpose of sending this one time e-mail.